Black Mountain Outfitters Reviews & Experiences

We strive to provide you with the trophy hunting experience of a lifetime.  Your satisfaction and feedback are of the utmost importance to us.  Below, you will find a small sampling of some of our Black Mountain Outfitters reviews.

“We’ve worked with more than 350 lodges, outfitters, and guides over the last decade to produce the highest rated outdoor shows in America.  It takes top shelf outfitters to make a premium TV series and Black Mountain shines at the top of the heap.”

Chris Dorsey
Orion Entertainment


“My elk hunt with Black Mountain Outfitters was fantastic. I have hunted all over the world, but chasing big bugling bull elk in New Mexico was a thrill.  The camp and staff were great and the hunting was exciting and memorable. This was a hunt I will never forget and I took a trophy that will help me tell the story for years to come. BMO was top notch and so was the hunting.”  

Mark W. DeYoung
CEO, Federal Premium Ammunition
President & CEO, ATK


“I’ve been hunting for about 40 years now and recently have expanded beyond Midwestern Whitetails. Hunting with your group was a true hunting experience. We hunted hard, ate well (and slept well), and saw a lot of huge bulls in a beautiful part of the country. If I didn’t already have a hunt booked for 2013 I’d be back next fall. I will see you in ’14.”

David Donna


“I have hunted with Tom McReynolds and Black Mountain Outfitters, Inc., 3 times and am going back in Sept. 2013 for the 4th time. I have hunted with bow and muzzleloader. Last fall I killed a nice 6×6 with my crossbow.  Tom runs a very good hunt.  He has a very comfortable camp with individual cabins and a large central meeting camp for eating and socializing. I think that the guides he has are all very good and professional. I think that if you are looking to go elk hunting, you should definitely give Tom a call. They have lots of elk and the quality is very good also. I can be reached at 785-242-4109.”

Ed Taylor
Ottawa, Kansas


“Hope to hunt with Black Mountain Outfitters again. Definitely an awesome place and experience.”

Keith Duncan
Newell Rubbermaid Inc.


“For the serious trophy elk hunter, Black Mountain Outfitters is for you. The professional guides are first class, accommodations are superb, the cook is as good as it gets, excellent food and abundant. The New Mexico hunting ranch is beautiful and produces world class trophy elk. I hunted seasons 2011, 2012, and have booked for 2013. Their dedication and attention to detail is excellent. The hunting experience with Black Mountain Outfitters was exceptional. Owner Tom McReynolds demands nothing less than 100% professionalism and effort for his operations and guides. The terrain on the New Mexico ranch is pretty easy going for the most part. If you are looking to book a trophy elk hunting trip I highly recommend Black Mountain Outfitters. Tom McReynolds knows his ranch, guides, and elk very well from years of hunting experience which shall give you the best opportunity for a trophy bull elk. I have been to multiple states and ranches over the last 26 years and have hunted with multiple outfitters. Tom McReynolds outfitting is one of the best outfitters in which I have hunted.”

Jeff Beaver
Olympia Construction, Inc. – Albertville, AL


“I have worked with BMO as both a client and hunt consultant.  All of my clients in 2012 were successful and took great bucks in the first few days of the hunt.  I was very happy with my personal hunt, and I am already booked to hunt with Tom and company again.  If you want a quality hunt with top notch people, look no further than Black Mountain Outfitters.”

Tim Herald, Host/Producer
Nosler’s Magnum TV and The Zone
Outdoor Writer
Hunt Consultant- Magnum Consulting


“If you want a big bull from the desert Southwest than you need to check out Black Mountain Outfitters. Tom and the Black Mountain crew do a great job of putting their clients on big desert bulls and the camp is always a good time.”

Guy Eastman
Eastmans Hunting Journal/Eastman Hunting TV


“Awesome hunt, incredibly knowledgeable guide and outfitter, have kept in contact with for several years after the hunt and plan to be back.”

Scott Albright
Cedar Rapids, Iowa


“I have hunted twice with BMO & had a great experience each time. I have bow hunted for elk in Colorado, Montana, & Oregon. We were into some of the biggest bulls I have ever hunted. The guys at Black Mountain Outfitters will get you into the elk. They are good people & will work hard for your success. Good accommodations, great food, & people that share the passion of the hunt for big bull elk.  I will hunt New Mexico again with Black Mountain Outfitters.”

Lisa Endicott
The Bow Rack
Springfield, Oregon

Sign Up To BMO Hunts

Please enter your email address to receive updates

Join 1,412 other subscribers



Now You Can WIN
The Hunt of A Lifetime!

Trophy Elk, Mule Deer, Antelope & More!

Enter Here! No Thanks. I'll Enter To Win Later.